back to article Geeks and Nerds caught on film lacking geeky nerdiness

Canada was shocked to its honest-to-goodness core this week by the news that the country's PC repairmen are undermining its sweet as maple syrup image. Canadian TV show CBC Marketplace did a hidden camera investigation into computer repair firms to see how many technicians could correctly fix a hardware problem. Of the 10 …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.

Page:

  1. teacake

    @CJ

    "am I the only one not seeing anything?"

    Oh, if you can't see the film it means your motherboard is broken.

  2. ryan
    Dead Vulture

    "You work with computers?"

    "can you just take a look at my PC a moment? it wont start, and sometimes it makes a buzzing noise, and i want to install this VOIP phone thingy? it won't take 5 mins i'm sure"

    I don't normally have the heart to tell them that as a web designer, i know fuck all about computers. i'm going to invest in a "NO! I WONT FIX YOUR COMPUTER" t-shirt.

  3. Gordon

    Ah, well....

    Oh, i'll always take a look at a friend or family member's PC. I don't charge, it's something called a "favour". They might cook me lunch, I'll fix their PC as they're my friend/relative.

    As for the "blown" memory. Just what does this mean? Are we talking "PC will not start" style blown or "when it gets warm it crashes windows" style blown Most competant repair people will try taking memory out of a PC that will not boot as we know it does fail and cause unpredictable problems. But if the thing boots and then fails later, you'd look at O/S file problems and hard-disk corruption first (well, I would).

    Diagnosis is often just "playing the numbers" you look at the most likely cause first, test for it, and if it's not there you move on - and sometimes there is nothing to tell you what order to try things in. So it's pure luck whether you try the right thing first or last.

  4. Christopher Hall

    Obviously...

    Not heard of MemTest86 then?

    These cretinous 'geeks' make my blood boil. I make it my business to accompany friends and family into places like PCWorld should they require me so they don't get the nonsense, sell-it-quick sales patter that often supercedes thoughtful, technical advice. I've had too many people consult me for advice having been dealt with by no more than over-insentivised sales staff with little to no knowledge about what they're selling.

    We need a proper IT cohort that is driven by customer's needs, not it's shareholders, like an IT co-op I suppose. Thoughts welcome.

  5. Anonymous Coward
    Dead Vulture

    Cowboys everywhere

    Its the same no matter what industry. Builders, plumbers, sparkies, double glazing and now "nerds". Last time i was in a car garage for repairs they'd tried to fleece me because the average punter doesn't know much about cars. They got put in their place. Also it would help if we got some damn respect for out jobs. I started out as tech and moved up to specicialise in networks. The lack of respect people have because they know nothing about computers is ridiculous. Finally its not new the i.t. industry ripping off people, just look at how much "consultants" charge and how often their installs go tits up. It wont be long before the tech guy wears trousers that shows off their crack. Dont worry though, ITIL will sort it all out (sigh).

  6. Todd Franklin

    They didn't call ME

    If the machine wouldn't POST, memory is one of the FIRST things you check. Here in southern Missouri, USA, we have many rural dial-up users and we occasionally have thunderstorms. Therefore, usually no-POST issues are either the modem or power supply (depending on whether the lightning struck a power line or the phone line.) If you eliminate those 2 problems, the next thing to do is pull the memory and see if your motherboard beeps at you. It helps to have a 25$ post-code checker, but it's not entirely necessary. If the machine will POST, but you're having flaky problems, then run a bootable diagnostic tool like pc-check to check your processor, motherboard, memory, and hard drive.

    The problem with many of these "geeksquad" type services is that they're not interested in fixing your computer. They are about selling product. They DON'T WANT to fix your computer and they DON'T CARE about you. An honest computer tech is like an honest mechanic, once you find one you can trust, stick with him (or her) and tell all your friends.

  7. Demian Phillips
    Coat

    You keep using that word...

    "On the penultimate day of this MCSE course, the person I shared a desk with, turned to me and whispered "What's a browser?"... I was speechless and numb with shock."

    So what was the ultimate day of the MCSE course?

Page:

This topic is closed for new posts.