Right of Reply
Ok let's start this over.
>>> Yes, let's...
consider the facts:
>>> What you meant to type here was "shut up and listen to my opinion".. big difference between your opinion and fact I am afraid.
- The Apple design department is arguably the best in the world, in any industry.
>>> Arguably is a good word because I can think of a whole bunch of people who would. If you mean Graphics Design (the art of making things look pretty) then please state Graphics Design. This is a tech website, therefore "Design Dept" usually means Technical Design ie Engineering (Hard or Soft), and trust me, Apple do NOT have the best Dept in that respect. If they did, no one would be able pick any holes in the iHype, I mean iPhone.
- Phones are status symbols so looks are extremely important
>>>To a certain market yes, to others no. Stop generalising.
Those two facts would tell you that Apple is in the mobile phone market to stay. To rule.
>>>They would be if they were true. Personally I reckon yes, sad to say, Apple is here to stay, but not as a major player.
then there are other facts:
- Apple has a real operating system which beats the pants off of symbian or win mobile, which can do things the others can only dream about
>>> Ok, can't comment on this, my field is hardware.
- Apple has the imagination to invent new things that people actually want
>>> No, Apple has the PR Dept to create the hype to convince people they want what Apple is selling. Big difference
- Apple has proven that they can make a working phone. Entering a new market is a huge risk and a huge effort, but it's already behind them. They will only get better after that.
>>> Well, no, the tech articles all agree that it's not a terribly good phone.
Yes, the other manufacturers are running around like headless chickens. Because they should.
>>>Gotta disagree, I don't exactly think Sony and Nokia are quaking in their boots.
I see only one flaw in Apple's mobile business - being too greedy and wanting a cut of the operator's income. It worked with AT&T but that's because AT&T really needs the iPhone, it won't work with (many) others, and it has the potential to severely hamper Apple. If I had to bet, I'd say Apple will adapt and get over this though.
>>>The flaws have been discussed to death (greed is just one of 'em), but there are three Camps.. Rabid Pro Apple, Rabid Anti Apple and the 3rd camp, the one I am most happy sat in, the "Couldn't really give a monkies who made it, is it any good?" camp.
Oh, and Rhett? We've all got to drop everything and only listen to you?? Go away. We're all entitled to have our own opinions. Some of us inherently prefer a product to do something we want. Fine if iHype does it for you, but it doesn't do it for everyone. For a bunch of us it's a dismal piece of pretty fluff.
<rant mode off>